Sugar PieSugar Pie

Midway Farmers Market · Saturdays 10 am – 1 pm

Little pies,
made by hand,
every Saturday.

Five-inch pies you don't have to share. Baked Friday night in Midway, Utah, gone by noon at the market.

Key lime mini pie with whipped cream and lime zest
MIDWAY FARMERS MARKET · SATURDAYS 10–1 · EST. 2026 ·SAT10–1

In the case right now

Live from the stall. Updates the moment something sells out, Saturdays 10 am – 1 pm.

Between markets the case is empty and this board goes quiet. The full lineup is below.

The pies

Five-inch pies — perfect for trying a new flavor, sharing with someone you love, or getting one of each. The case follows the season: pumpkin, apple and pecan in fall; rhubarb and peach in summer.

Mini pies5"

  • Key Lime

    Key Lime

    $7

    Tart, cool, whipped cream and zest

  • PumpkinFall

    Pumpkin

    $7

    Spiced custard, flaky crust, pastry leaves on top

  • PecanFall

    Pecan

    $8

    Butter, brown sugar and an oh-so-flaky crust

  • AppleFall

    Apple

    $7

    Hand-woven lattice, cinnamon apples

  • B

    Banana Cream

    $7

    Vanilla custard, sliced banana, cream

  • Chocolate Cream

    Chocolate Cream

    $7

    Dark chocolate custard, cocoa shavings

  • C

    Coconut Cream

    $7

    Toasted coconut, whipped cream

  • Cherry

    Cherry

    $7

    Lattice top, tart cherries

  • R
    Summer

    Rhubarb

    $7

    Lattice top, tart rhubarb

Full pies9"

  • Chocolate Coconut Dream

    Chocolate Coconut Dream

    $32

    Ganache-lined crust, coconut cream, a tower of whipped cream, toasted coconut and a chocolate drizzle

  • PumpkinFall

    Pumpkin

    $28

    Feeds eight

Tarts

  • Peach & Blueberry TartSummer

    Peach & Blueberry Tart

    $8

    Pastry cream, fresh fruit

This Saturday

Where
Midway Farmers Market
Midway Town Square
When
Saturdays, 10 am – 1 pm
through October
Tip
Minis sell out first. Check what's in the case before you walk over, or reserve yours below.
A table of pies at the marketPumpkin pies of every size

Reserve a pie

Message us by Thursday night with what you'd like and how many. We'll have it boxed and waiting Saturday at the market.

Planning a party or Thanksgiving? Full pies need a week's notice.

DM @sugar_pie_bakery_coText (435) 555-0142

Gluten-free pies are in the works — DM if you'd like to taste-test.